The Hindu : Sport : England not well prepared

Online edition of India's National Newspaper
Wednesday, Mar 01, 2006

Sport

Sport

England not well prepared

With a longer build-up to the Tests, England could have sorted out the injury problems, writes Geoff Boycott

The TVS Cup Test series is shaping up into a bit of a David vs. Goliath battle, only I think the ending will deviate from mythology and Goliath will end up winning the contest!

At the best of times, defeating India at home is not easy — hardly any touring team has done it — and given the current state of the England squad, I am afraid the conclusion to the series may be foregone.

From experience, I can safely say that the keys to series in India are spinners and batsmen.

So where are the English spinners? Shaun Udal, Monty Panesar and Ian Blackwell are hardly likely to strike fear into the hearts of the imposing Indian batting line-up. Frankly, I hadn't heard of Panesar until this series, and there are probably half-a-dozen better spinners than him playing on the Calcutta maidan!

Cupboard looks bare

As for the batsmen, with Michael Vaughan and Marcus Trescothick out of the picture, the cupboard looks a little bare, doesn't it? The thing is, preparation is everything, whatever the job. And England just has not had enough of it.

I know the idea these days is to have shorter tours with back-to-back games squeezed in so that the players don't have to be away from home for too long. That is the modern way and I completely disagree with it. I may be old-fashioned but I think it's all wrong.

Why? Well, for one, there aren't enough practice matches. In my days, we would play a minimum of four practice matches before the series proper, which meant we were on tour for months. Indeed, our 1981-82 Indian tour lasted nearly four months, comprising six Tests and three ODIs.

What can you expect when you take youngsters like Alastair Cook and Owais Shah, who have never played in India, and throw them into a Test match? They are not mugs, mind you, but they simply do not have the preparation to play India in India.

And this is where England are making things difficult for themselves. Look at all the niggling injuries that are troubling the players.

Given a longer build-up to the Tests and at least two more four-day matches, they would have sorted these niggles out and still have had time to play themselves in, unlike someone like Kevin Pietersen, for instance, who will come straight from an injury into a pressure situation.

Poor Freddie

Poor Andrew Flintoff. Ordinarily, he should be thrilled to bits about the captaincy and it ought to be one of the proudest moments of his life. But in my 25 years of playing and 20 years as commentator, I cannot think of a worse time to be the England captain.

Make no mistake, Flintoff will take it in his stride because he has been the England team's best player and its focal point for the past two years anyway. He has shouldered all the expectations and delivered every time.

He never bowls badly, is the best slip catcher in England since Ian Botham, and a terrific cricketer all round, not to mention a smashing lad off the field.

Gameplan

Printer friendly page
Send this article to Friends by E-Mail