The Hindu : Front Page : The ‘$100’ laptop tussle

Online edition of India's National Newspaper
Saturday, Mar 15, 2008
ePaper | Mobile/PDA Version

Front Page

Front Page

The ‘$100’ laptop tussle

Lawsuits over keyboard press on against One Laptop Per Child group

CAMBRIDGE: A potential $20 million problem for the group behind the ‘$100 laptop’ is not going away easily.

Ade Oyegbola, an inventor who claims that the One Laptop Per Child (OLPC) non-profit stole his designs for a Nigerian keyboard, recently won a round in a Lagos court. This week he is pressing his case in a U.S. court.

The dispute began last year. One Laptop Per Child, spun out of the Massachusetts Institute of Technology by Nicholas Negroponte, was sued by Mr. Oyegbola’s company, Lagos Analysis Corp., known as Lancor.

Nigerian dialects require punctuation marks not found on standard English keyboards, so Lancor developed a keyboard that uses four shift keys to produce the symbols. Mr. Oyegbola claims that OLPC bought two of Lancor’s keyboards in 2006, then copied the design for its own models intended for sale in Nigeria.

“It was obvious to anybody who looked at it.”

Lancor filed a patent lawsuit seeking $20 million in damages in Nigeria, and last month a court there rejected OLPC’s bid to dismiss the case.

Restraining order

The court extended a restraining order prohibiting OLPC from distributing its laptops in the country.

Separately, OLPC asked a court in Massachusetts, where Lancor has an office, to clear it of any wrongdoing. This week, that case moved to a federal court, where Lancor filed a counterclaim alleging violation of trade secrets.

A spokesman for OLPC had no comment. When Lancor’s lawsuit first emerged, the organisation said that as far as it knew, “all of the intellectual property used in the XO laptop is either owned by OLPC or properly licensed.”

The keyboard lawsuit is one of a few setbacks for OLPC, which has got its laptops to fewer children than it first expected and at roughly twice the originally sought price of $100.

Even so, the group now claims to have gotten orders for a half a million machines for children in countries including Peru, Uruguay, Mongolia, Rwanda, Haiti and Afghanistan. — AP

Printer friendly page
Send this article to Friends by E-Mail

Front Page