Opinion - News Analysis   

S-300s for Iran: an argument for peace

The likelihood of Russia supplying S-300 surface-to-air systems to Iran has always been a headache for the United States and its allies. For several years the media has reported the conclusion of a contract or even the actual shipment of long-range air defence missiles to Iran. As a rule, these reports came from Iranian sources and were later denied by Russia.

On December 17, 2008, RIA Novosti, quoting confidential sources, reported on its website that Russia is to deliver S-300 surface-to-air systems to Iran. Which, based on previous experience, is most likely true. How will the balance of strength change in this region if Iran really gets the systems?

Before considering an answer, it is necessary to see what weapons Iran’s armed forces will receive .

It has been repeatedly stated that Iran expects to get five battalions of S-300PMUs, or up to 20 systems (60 launchers), depending on the make-up of a battalion. Each of the launchers carries four 48N6E missiles (48N6E2s with the PMU-2 mobile launchers) with a range of 150 kilometres (up to 200 kilometres for the 48N6E2s). Each launch system consists of three launchers and is capable of engaging six targets at the same time, aiming 12 missiles at them. One battalion consisting of four systems is, therefore, capable of dealing with 24 aircraft simultaneously. After changing position and replenishing ammunition, it can be quickly re-deployed for repulsing a repeat raid.

It should be remembered that S-300 missiles themselves need to be protected - for this purpose Iran can use Tor-M1 surface-to-air missiles (SAMs) and Chinese FM-80s. Coupled with S-300s, these short-range missiles can set up a credible air defence system able to protect the facility covered and itself. In this tandem, S-300s will act as a long arm to shoot down sophisticated targets at long distances, while close-in weapons will protect the facility and S-300s from cruise missiles, aircraft and UAVs that break through.

Five battalions of S-300 SAMs will contribute significantly not only to the protection of designated facilities, but also to the defence capability of the country as a whole. Deliveries of new SAMs will make it possible to move old systems to other parts of the country, increasing its air defence density. Should Iran have time to deploy the Russian systems and to control the grouping, the overall damage from air defences may exceed the threshold acceptable to Iran’s potential opponents. S-300s do not, of course, guarantee Iran’s invincibility or invulnerability. — RIA Novosti

Printer friendly page  
Send this article to Friends by E-Mail

Stories in this Section

Height of irresponsibility
A silver lining
Crises today and the future of capitalism
Portents of insurance amendments
The latest crisis of trust
‘Bush shoe’ gives a Turk firm footing
S-300s for Iran: an argument for peace
Sharif’s disclosure
Beyond defence
Welcome
Unfortunate
Relevant
On playing cricket
When caution is the preferred option

Copyright © 2008, The Hindu. Republication or redissemination of the contents of this screen are expressly prohibited without the written consent of The Hindu